It’s a Wonderful Life is, to this day – and I’ve seen it perhaps dozens of times – fascinating. At its simplest, it is about “how one man’s life touches so many others.” The Capra formula. But the other night the thing that struck me for the first time, after all these viewings, is how much fun Pottersville is: bars everywhere, show-houses, music spilling into the streets. And this is Christmas Eve! It’s just about the liveliest downtown you could ask for. It is interesting to me that Capra saw this as the banker’s (Potter’s) triumph. A descent into rampant Sin, I guess he was saying (the movie seems to be, up to this point, about real estate, and now it’s about morality) … although that isn’t how it went with Mary Hatch… But I ask you: has anyone ever bought Donna Reed, with that perfect face and perfect figure, as a spinster? Even as a mousy librarian she still looks pretty damn good. What Capra should have done right there, if he wanted to turn everything on its head (in what became known on the set as the “unborn sequence”), was made sexy Violet Bick into the librarian and proper Mary Hatch into the hard-partying barroom tart. (Donna Reed, I’m going to guess, would have eaten that right up.) Imagine how horrifying a vision that would have been for George. Also, why was Bailey Park transformed into a graveyard – instead of into a more opulent subdivision? Wouldn’t a banker want a subdivision? You could argue that sedate Bedford Falls is more of a banker’s paradise than Pottersville is. Pottersville, which, in its unholy trashiness, seems completely of the people, something that arose from the bottom. I think a nightmarish vision of unrestrained capitalism would look quite different nowadays from what Capra envisioned.
Anyway, the other thing I took away from the movie the other night is how little George Bailey, for all his expressed regard for the ordinary working people of Bedford Falls, really trusts them. He doesn’t. He doesn’t trust them to take care of themselves and he doesn’t trust them to take care of him. He’s condescended to them all these years, and it has poisoned his soul. He never wanted to be a part of that crowd at all. Stewart is brilliant in the role.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.